Helping consulting firms
to create high quality thought leadership

previous next
KPMG global tech report 2023—securing value by navigating uncertainty with confidence​
Path: /review/660980/kpmg-global-tech-report-2023%E2%80%94securing-value-navigating-uncertainty-confidence%E2%80%8B
Button
Score: Differentiation:
3.00
Score: Appeal:
3.40
Score: Resilience:
3.25
Score: Prompting Action:
2.33
Firm name:
KPMG
Body:
In this report, KPMG share insight from their survey of digital transformation leaders, demonstrating why, despite economic uncertainty, they’re still committed to technological innovation in a bid to drive efficiency and productivity gains. They also provide the reader with an opportunity to understand where their business sits in comparison to the others with insight from experts in the marketplace.​ With proprietary data from an in-depth survey of over 2000 executives from 16 countries, this is an impressive piece of quantitative research that is enhanced further by a suite of executive interviews that not only add colour but also practical insight to support the narrative. This combination helps differentiate this from other technology reports in the market and strengthens KPMG’s credibility in this area.​​ The landing page is compelling and well designed, and the visuals within the PDF are a strong execution of the KPMG brand. The landscape format and subtle but effective digital navigational tools really aid the user experience and help to make it a captivating read.​​ The report concludes with a set of considerations and questions that the reader can take into their own business. Although this could be enhanced with a little more depth and clarity of the key action points, they do leave the reader with a clear idea of what the next steps could be as they consider their own digital transformation.
Make quantum readiness real​
Path: /review/659213/make-quantum-readiness-real%E2%80%8B
Button
Score: Differentiation:
3.33
Score: Appeal:
3.20
Score: Resilience:
4.00
Score: Prompting Action:
2.67
Firm name:
IBM
Body:
This highly differentiated and distinctive report from the IBM Institute for Business Value (IBM IBV) leverages a wealth of research that culminates in a Quantum Readiness Index (QRI). The QRI indicates where organisations fall along a readiness spectrum, what characteristics define a quantum-ready organisation (QRO), and what targeted actions can propel organisations along their quantum journey. ​ With proprietary, self-reported data from an in-depth survey of C-suite executives representing 565 organisations with annual revenues of $250 million or more, this is a first-class example of research backed thought leadership that introduces new thinking in a dynamic way, while demonstrating IBM's credibility to talk on this topic. ​ The report is brought to life through strong data visualisations that not only tell the research story but also highlight the key takeaways for the reader. In addition, the use of case studies gives this piece an "of the market" feel, as well as highlighting IBM's capability to support organisations on their quantum readiness journey. ​ The concluding set of recommendations are specific and actionable, and provide the reader with a very clear sense of how they should take this insight and use it within their own organisation.
The State of Organizations in 2023: Ten shifts transforming organizations
Path: /review/657712/state-organizations-2023-ten-shifts-transforming-organizations
Button
Score: Differentiation:
3.33
Score: Appeal:
4.00
Score: Resilience:
3.50
Score: Prompting Action:
2.33
Firm name:
McKinsey
Body:
This report is an account of McKinsey's ongoing research initiative that seeks both to pinpoint the most important shifts that organisations are grappling with and to provide business leaders with some ideas and suggestions about how to approach them.​ From the off, this report is impressive. The landing page does an exceptional job of engaging the audience, with a strong introduction and dynamic, interactive navigation through the key report takeaways. ​ Within the downloadable PDF, the visual depiction of data points is creative, yet clear, and strong and on-brand imagery is used to break up the text and ensure continued engagement. Graphics have also been designed to translate across different mediums, aiding accessibility and demonstrating McKinsey's awareness of their target audience's preferences. ​ The report is built on a sound and comprehensive data set, all of which is clearly explained in a brief methodology upfront, followed by a detailed description of the research programme at the end.​ "Lessons from leaders", included on the landing page, provide an interesting perspective on the qualitative data collected for the report, supported by short biographies of the interviewees which demonstrates their credibility to speak on this topic. ​ To conclude, a set of high-level takeaways are provided, augmented with detailed recommendations and action points for the reader that encourage onward conversation within their business.
Healthier at home: Creating value for all in the shift from hospital to home
Path: /review/649028/healthier-home-creating-value-all-shift-hospital-home
Button
Score: Differentiation:
3.00
Score: Appeal:
2.60
Score: Resilience:
2.75
Score: Prompting Action:
3.33
Firm name:
PA Consulting
Body:
'Healthier at home' outlines why the health and social care market is entering a new era of radical growth in preventative, personalised treatments that maximise positive health outcomes and system resilience. It identifies four key ways to create maximum value across the ecosystem that will deliver value for all. The introduction to this piece provides a very solid summary of the core narrative and positions the argument well for the reader. It also demonstrates the credibility of PA in this territory early on with a key data point—“our research suggests that by 2030, the global market for these solutions will increase by $70 billion to $390.4 billion” - a great hook. The use of the four accelerators as the core element of this report helps make it feel relevant and differentiated from other content in the market. ​ The report shows good professional design and layout which brings the PA brand to life. Strong use of relevant imagery within the divider pages and good use of pull-out quotes and highlights on key messaging help keep the user engaged and ensure the report is appealing. ​ A strong and targeted sample and data set combined with good examples and case studies from the market shows depth of research and insight. In addition, the authors and life sciences tech experts are positioned right at the front of the report which helps further enhance PA's credibility to speak on this topic. This piece concludes with a set of strong action points laid out across all four accelerators provide a great list of key takeaways for the reader. These are enhanced with a set of examples and case studies that bring these recommendations to life. To complement this, a very thorough “how we can help” section at the end helps reinforce PA's capability in this area, and is a very effective, repeatable element in PA’s thought leadership approach.
The reinvention reset: From bold plans to pragmatic actions​
Path: /review/642589/reinvention-reset-bold-plans-pragmatic-actions%E2%80%8B
Button
Score: Differentiation:
3.00
Score: Appeal:
3.00
Score: Resilience:
3.75
Score: Prompting Action:
2.67
Firm name:
Accenture
Body:
As a sequel to a 2021 report by Accenture, this highly targeted report looks at how oil and gas companies are meeting the challenges of the energy transition and advancing their reinvention strategies. This sharpness of focus and target audience helps with differentiation and the clarity of the value proposition for the piece. Their enterprise-wide reinvention involves rethinking the strategies, technologies and operating models in five areas: Competitiveness, Carbon, Connectivity, Customers and Culture (the 5Cs) and their research showcases how and why leading companies in the industry are progressing across these transformation areas.​ While the sample for the primary research is not large, there is good specificity in the types of oil and gas companies they engaged. The analysis created Reinvention Index scores and three typologies - Leaders, Followers and Laggards and explored the characteristics of each. We liked the light touch methodology up front followed by more detailed information at the back, and the early positioning of the authors landed well. Accenture’s thought leadership has a consistently strong brand treatment and is at the leading edge of engagement, this report is a prime example of where great design is augmented by a clear brand voice. Pieces like this make excellent use of additional assets such as video and data visualisation, while not distracting from the focus of the report. That said, the ‘slide’ style of the design leads to it being a lengthy piece overall (close to 100 pages), which will test the patience of some. There are calls to action threaded throughout, even though the recommended actions are a little light. This report is also a good example of how Accenture consistently invests in strong research to support their thought leadership, which is often multi-dimensional in approach and increasingly innovative. ​
Can Europe Catch Up with the US (and China) in Quantum Computing?
Path: /review/623672/can-europe-catch-us-and-china-quantum-computing
Button
Score: Differentiation:
3.67
Score: Appeal:
3.00
Score: Resilience:
3.75
Score: Prompting Action:
2.67
Firm name:
BCG
Body:
This high scoring piece of thought leadership from BCG’s Henderson Institute looks at how and why the European Union (EU) needs to capture some of the benefits of quantum systems and improve its current position against other countries who are far more advanced. They describe the emergent risks and explain why the EU can only realistically hope to succeed in the quantum computing industry, retain competitiveness and technological independence by tackling these challenges. ​​ This report is a good example of BCG’s ability to differentiate its content and explore more whitespace territory. The depth and sophistication of data sources and analysis here is excellent. In-depth profiles of authors also give a greater sense of authority.